Report · ivan-gavran.github.io
The Case Against Formal Verification, 50 Years Later

ivan-gavran.github.io
Source published August 16, 2026
Summary: 1 min read
49/100
Summary
Interest in software verification has surged, with a notable increase in Google Trends searches for formal verification and formal methods over the past two years. Many engineers are now learning Lean and exploring new specification languages, indicating a growing excitement around the topic.
Key Takeaways
- There has been a significant increase in interest in formal verification and methods, as evidenced by a spike in Google Trends searches over the last two years.
- AI coding has created a demand for software correctness assurance due to the lack of understanding of AI-generated programs.
- The 1979 paper "Social Processes and Proofs of Theorems and Programs" argues that program verification is unlikely to affect confidence in programs, a claim that is being re-examined in light of recent developments.
- Modern specification languages, like Quint, facilitate the verification of specifications against informal requirements, addressing concerns about the translation process from informal to formal specifications.
Coverage & discussions
Hacker News · ivan-gavran.github.io
Community discussions
Community Sentiment
Positives
- Lean's powerful type system allows for making invalid states unrepresentable, a feature that stands out in the formal verification landscape.
- Building a formally verified workflow engine in Lean was surprisingly easy for one user, highlighting its potential for creating reliable systems.
- Empirical evidence from CompCert shows that formal verification can lead to high confidence in compiler correctness, outperforming traditional testing methods.
Concerns
- Many commenters doubt the reliability of formal verification, questioning whether the specifications are inherently more correct than the implementations they verify.
- The model-code gap remains a significant hurdle, with users struggling to find straightforward methods to bridge the gap between formal models and actual code.
- Concerns linger that increased computational power doesn't necessarily favor formal verification over extensive testing, leaving some skeptical about its practical advantages.
Related Articles

Why don't people use formal methods? (2019)
Jul 30, 2026

What can you confidently guarantee about your software?
Jun 29, 2026

LLMs are making formal software verification feasible at a much larger scale
Oct 22, 2026

When AI writes the software, who verifies it?
Mar 3, 2026

The Fall of the Theorem Economy
Jul 2, 2026