Themata.AI
Follow coverage
Themata.AI

AI delivers ‘zero financial payoff’ to most companies, Apollo economist says

techcrunch.com ·

Apollo Global Management chief economist Torsten Slok said artificial intelligence has delivered “zero financial payoff” to large U.S. companies outside the technology sector. In a recent note, Slok examined the “S&P 493,” defined as the S&P 500 excluding Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla. He found that profit margins and revenue per worker appear flat, with no evidence that AI is improving productivity across those companies.

Slok said massive AI investment and widespread adoption have not translated into higher revenue growth or profit margins for corporate America beyond major technology firms. He questioned whether non-tech companies can convert increasingly inexpensive AI capabilities into financial gains, arguing that business performance depends heavily on judgment rather than intelligence alone.

Slok said AI does not understand accountability, trust, organizational culture, unwritten rules, ethical trade-offs, or fairness. He argued that those factors shape reputational risk and ultimately affect revenue growth and profit margins. Recent studies have also found that AI has not yet produced significant productivity gains.

Read original ↗

What people are saying

The thread mostly rejected the idea that AI’s value can be judged by a company’s top-line revenue alone, but it did not treat faster work as proof of financial return.

What readers liked

  • In technical research workflows, AI can compress idea-to-prototype cycles from weeks to a day, freeing scientists to test possibilities they…
  • AI’s strongest commercial wins may be boring embedded applications, where smoother expense handling or infrastructure configuration saves users…

Concerns raised

  • Faster experimentation does not automatically improve the bottom line when most additional trials fail and companies cannot show the resulting…
  • When rivals adopt the same models, productivity gains can be competed away, leaving businesses to pay AI vendors simply to avoid falling behind.
View discussion ↗
Read full discussion analysis

Source: Hacker News · Based on 15 sampled comments · Analyzed

Discussion overview

The thread mostly rejected the idea that AI’s value can be judged by a company’s top-line revenue alone, but it did not treat faster work as proof of financial return. One concrete example came from specialty chemistry and data science: AI removes enough data-processing and coding overhead to turn a one- or two-week route from idea to prototype into a day, letting researchers test a much wider set of candidate formulations. Others pointed to mundane deployed products, such as expense management and cloud configuration, as evidence that useful AI often hides inside unglamorous workflows rather than headline-grabbing demos.

The hard question was whether these gains survive contact with a real business. Several readers demanded public evidence of revenue growth, margin improvement, or cost savings rather than anecdotes about productivity. They argued that generating more experiments, drafts, or possibilities can simply accelerate dead ends. Others added that gains may be competed away: if every firm buys similar models, AI becomes a recurring provider fee required just to maintain position. Critics also challenged the Apollo analysis itself, saying revenue snapshots cannot establish the counterfactual economic return on AI spending. The prevailing mood was neither dismissal nor triumphalism: AI is visibly valuable in fitting tasks, while broad claims of immediate corporate payoff remain unproven and badly measured.

Points of disagreement

Does AI-assisted productivity already amount to meaningful corporate financial payoff? Advocates argue that removing technical bottlenecks expands experimentation, product development, and customer-facing capacity, so firms failing to convert that into value have an execution problem. Skeptics counter that speed is not profit: without credible counterfactuals and public margin or revenue data, more output may be wasted effort or merely an expensive competitive necessity.

What readers liked

  • In technical research workflows, AI can compress idea-to-prototype cycles from weeks to a day, freeing scientists to test possibilities they previously had to discard.
  • AI’s strongest commercial wins may be boring embedded applications, where smoother expense handling or infrastructure configuration saves users effort without generating social-media spectacle.
  • Several readers see today’s weak aggregate returns as an early-adoption problem, comparable to judging an immature technological wave before organizations redesign work around it.
  • For non-programmer domain experts, AI lowers the cost of data processing and custom tooling enough to turn stalled analytical ideas into executable experiments.

Concerns raised

  • Faster experimentation does not automatically improve the bottom line when most additional trials fail and companies cannot show the resulting revenue, margin, or cost savings.
  • When rivals adopt the same models, productivity gains can be competed away, leaving businesses to pay AI vendors simply to avoid falling behind.
  • AI magnifies both conscientious workers and low-quality output producers, making it far harder to detect polished-looking but useless generated work.
  • Even highly productive AI users remain constrained by slow sales processes and organizational bureaucracy, so local gains may never reach company-level results.

Keep reading

  • Anthropic's internal AI use, at retail prices, now exceeds its employee pay
  • AI promised less work. I've never worked more
  • Apollo says AI has delivered 'zero financial payoff' outside the tech industry
Sources and details
  • techcrunch.com · Published

    AI delivers ‘zero financial payoff’ to most companies, Apollo economist says

    Read report →

Community analysis available for 1 of 2 linked discussions.

Additional discussion searches are still incomplete.

Coverage details and dates

Latest available community analysis:

Summaries: 1 current · 0 awaiting update · 0 not verified

Latest summary update:

Discussion analysis: 1 unavailable

RSS · TechCrunch AI · techcrunch.com

AI delivers ‘zero financial payoff’ to most companies, Apollo economist says ↗
Hacker News discussion ↗

Reported comments: 1 · 1 saved in sample

Too few usable comments or discussion unavailable

Hacker News discussion ↗

Reported comments: 244 · 15 saved in sample

Analysis ready